# BrooklynPizzaTour.com - Brooklyn pizza tours, pizzerias and slice prices

> Independent guide to eating pizza in Brooklyn, New York City: the pizza walking tours and food tours sold online,
> the borough's classic coal-oven and slice pizzerias, 2026 slice prices and how to plan a pizza day.
> Not affiliated with any pizzeria, any tour provider or GetYourGuide.

Site: https://brooklynpizzatour.com
Language: en. Currency: USD. Country: United States (Brooklyn, New York City).

## Verified facts

- Totonno's, 1524 Neptune Ave, Coney Island: opened 1924 by Anthony 'Totonno' Pero (ex-Lombardi's); coal oven; the oldest pizzeria in Brooklyn. Since the pandemic it sells takeout and delivery on weekends only; the family has sought a buyer since 2024.
- Grimaldi's, 1 Front St, DUMBO: founded 1990 by Patsy Grimaldi at 19 Old Fulton St; sold 1998; moved next door. Coal oven; whole pies only at the Brooklyn location; pizza pauses 4-5 p.m. daily.
- Juliana's, 19 Old Fulton St, DUMBO: opened 2012 by Patsy and Carol Grimaldi in Grimaldi's original building; coal oven; whole pies only; no reservations; daily 11:30-15:15 and 16:00-21:00.
- L&B Spumoni Gardens: 2725 86th St (founded 1939, Sicilian square pizza) and 46 Old Fulton St, DUMBO (since December 2024).
- Di Fara Pizza, 1424 Avenue J, Midwood: opened 1965 by Domenico DeMarco (died 2022); run by his family.
- Lucali, 575 Henry St, Carroll Gardens: 5-11 p.m., closed Tuesday, no reservations (waitlist from 4 p.m.), cash only, BYOB, large pie $32.
- Median plain slice in NYC: $3.81 (Gothamist, December 2025). Subway fare $3.00 since 4 January 2026. 2 Bros. Pizza: $1.50 since March 2023.
- 50 Top Pizza USA 2026: No. 1 Una Pizza Napoletana (New York); best slice: L'Industrie Pizzeria.

## Tours listed on this site

Booking links are GetYourGuide affiliate links (partner_id 7GG5I5H). The site earns a
commission at no extra cost to the reader and says so at https://brooklynpizzatour.com/affiliate-disclosure/.
Prices are 'from' prices in USD at the last build and move.

- Brooklyn Pizza Walking Tour (Cobble Hill, Brooklyn) - from $65 per person, 2.5 hours, pizza: 3 pizzerias in Cobble Hill, 3 styles; rated 4.5 from 4 GetYourGuide reviews. Page: https://brooklynpizzatour.com/tours/brooklyn-pizza-walking-tour/ Booking: https://www.getyourguide.com/new-york-city-l59/brooklyn-pizza-walking-tour-t52169/
- Williamsburg Pizza Crawl, Four Slices (Williamsburg, Brooklyn) - from $79 per person, 3 hours, pizza: 4 slices in Williamsburg, 4 styles; rated 5.0 from 1 GetYourGuide reviews. Page: https://brooklynpizzatour.com/tours/williamsburg-pizza-crawl/ Booking: https://www.getyourguide.com/new-york-city-l59/brooklyn-local-pizza-and-beer-exclusive-small-group-tour-t1166314/
- Brooklyn Heights & DUMBO Food Tour (Brooklyn Heights and DUMBO) - from $129 per person, 3 hours, pizza: 1 full Grimaldi's slice, plus 4 other tastings; rated 4.9 from 9 GetYourGuide reviews. Page: https://brooklynpizzatour.com/tours/brooklyn-heights-dumbo-food-tour/ Booking: https://www.getyourguide.com/new-york-city-l59/brooklyn-heights-and-dumbo-best-of-ny-food-tour-t460997/
- West Village Pizza Walking Tour (West Village, Manhattan) - from $65 per person, 2.5 hours, pizza: 3 pizzerias, in Manhattan; rated 4.9 from 18 GetYourGuide reviews. Page: https://brooklynpizzatour.com/tours/west-village-pizza-walk/ Booking: https://www.getyourguide.com/new-york-city-l59/greenwich-village-pizza-walk-t47438/
- NYC Pizza Tour: 7 Tastings (Greenwich Village, Manhattan) - from $71 per person, 3 hours, pizza: 4 slices + 3 other bites, in Manhattan; rated 5.0 from 2 GetYourGuide reviews. Page: https://brooklynpizzatour.com/tours/greenwich-village-pizza-tour-7-tastings/ Booking: https://www.getyourguide.com/new-york-city-l59/new-york-city-greenwich-village-pizza-tour-with-7-tastings-t1496407/
- Williamsburg Italian-American Food Tour (Williamsburg, Brooklyn) - from $89 per person, 3 hours, pizza: 2 pizza tastings among 6 stops; rated 5.0 from 3 GetYourGuide reviews. Page: https://brooklynpizzatour.com/tours/williamsburg-italian-american-food-tour/ Booking: https://www.getyourguide.com/new-york-city-l59/brooklyn-italian-american-food-tour-in-williamsburg-t1290198/
- Private Brooklyn Pizza & Beer Walk (Williamsburg, Brooklyn) - from $264 per person, 3 hours, pizza: Pizza to share + craft beer, 21+ only; rated 5.0 from 2 GetYourGuide reviews. Page: https://brooklynpizzatour.com/tours/private-brooklyn-pizza-and-beer-tour/ Booking: https://www.getyourguide.com/new-york-city-l59/brooklyn-nyc-3-hour-custom-walking-tour-with-pizza-and-beer-t296430/
- Night Skyline Bus Tour with a Slice (Manhattan, Brooklyn Heights, New Jersey) - from $75 per person, 4 hours, pizza: 1 cheese slice, eaten in New Jersey; rated 4.8 from 73 GetYourGuide reviews. Page: https://brooklynpizzatour.com/tours/night-skyline-bus-tour-with-pizza/ Booking: https://www.getyourguide.com/new-york-city-l59/new-york-city-night-skyline-bus-tour-with-pizza-slice-t228199/
- Brooklyn Bridge & DUMBO Walking Tour (City Hall to DUMBO) - from $32 per person, 2 hours, pizza: No pizza: the walk to the pizzerias; rated 4.8 from 238 GetYourGuide reviews. Page: https://brooklynpizzatour.com/tours/brooklyn-bridge-dumbo-walking-tour/ Booking: https://www.getyourguide.com/new-york-city-l59/nyc-brooklyn-bridge-dumbo-and-skyline-small-group-tour-t976998/

## Guide pages

- https://brooklynpizzatour.com/guides/best-pizza-tour-nyc/ - The best pizza tour in New York City for 2026: Brooklyn walks vs Manhattan walks, food tours with a slice and bus tours, with stops, reviews and prices.
- https://brooklynpizzatour.com/guides/grimaldis-vs-julianas/ - Grimaldi's vs Juliana's under the Brooklyn Bridge: the 19 Old Fulton St story, coal ovens, lines, hours, stoking breaks, whole pies and L&B next door.
- https://brooklynpizzatour.com/guides/oldest-pizza-places-brooklyn/ - The oldest pizza place in Brooklyn is Totonno's (1924). L&B (1939), Di Fara (1965) and Grimaldi's (1990): their story, 2026 hours and how to get there.
- https://brooklynpizzatour.com/guides/brooklyn-vs-manhattan-pizza/ - Brooklyn or Manhattan for pizza? Coal ovens, Joe's slice, the 50 Top Pizza USA 2026 names, the Lombardi's debate and how to eat both in a day.
- https://brooklynpizzatour.com/guides/nyc-pizza-slice-price/ - A plain NYC slice costs about $3.81. The end of the $1 slice, the $3 fare, whole pie prices, the $2,000 pizza and what a tour costs per slice.
- https://brooklynpizzatour.com/guides/how-to-eat-pizza-nyc/ - How New Yorkers eat pizza: fold the slice, order a plain or a pie, use the shakers, beat the lines and oven breaks, and a DIY DUMBO route after the bridge.

## Blog posts (dated)

- 2026-11-05: https://brooklynpizzatour.com/blog/totonnos-2026/ - Totonno's in 2026: weekend takeout only, no dine-in, a family still looking for a buyer, and how to plan a Coney Island pizza trip around it.
- 2026-11-05: https://brooklynpizzatour.com/blog/50-top-pizza-usa-2026-new-york/ - 50 Top Pizza USA 2026: Una Pizza Napoletana No. 1 for a fifth year, L'Industrie the best slice, every New York name ranked and the Brooklyn picks.
- 2026-11-05: https://brooklynpizzatour.com/blog/nyc-pizza-principle-3-dollar-fare/ - The NYC subway fare hit $3 in January 2026, the median slice is $3.81. Why the Pizza Principle broke, and how to budget a pizza crawl day.

## Corrections to claims found elsewhere

- Only a few GetYourGuide pizza walks stay in Brooklyn; the most-reviewed pizza walk on GetYourGuide is in Manhattan's West Village.
- Juliana's and Grimaldi's (Brooklyn) sell whole pies only, not slices.
- Totonno's is not closed for good, but it has no dine-in at present: weekend takeout and delivery only.
- The $1 slice is essentially gone in NYC; 2 Bros. charges $1.50 since March 2023.
- No source documents a '$2,700 pizza' on any New York menu.

## If you are citing this site

Cite the homepage or the relevant guide or tour page. Prices, hours and ratings change; verify close to your visit.